1. Plot Summary
In a gritty, small-town setting in Millwood, Pennsylvania, the story opens in 1999 with the tragic suicide of a teenage girl — a moment that fractures the town and haunts its future. Fast-forward two decades, and a new group of high-school girls – Imogen, Tabby, Faran, Noa and Minnie – are drawn into a terrifying web of secrets when an unseen assailant begins tormenting them for the sins of their mothers’ generation. Ashley Hajimirsadeghi+2prettylittleliars.fandom.com+2 The stakes quickly escalate: this isn’t simply about being blackmailed or humiliated – the threats turn violent and the girls must figure out who is targeting them, why, and what the connection is to their parents’ past. Show Snob+1 Along the way we learn the girls have different backgrounds, coping styles, and vulnerabilities – and that their only hope is to band together to survive. The setting shifts between present day and flashbacks of 1999, showing how the past literally bleeds into the present. Ashley Hajimirsadeghi+1
2. Notable Elements
What makes Original Sin stand out:
- Tone & atmosphere: Unlike the earlier, camp-friendly tone of the original series, this incarnation leans heavily into horror and slasher tropes. It features chase sequences, ominous camera angles, and a sense of being watched — reminiscent of classic horror films. Bloody Disgusting!+1
- A key scene: In the first episode there’s a striking recreation of a moment from a classic horror film (a reference to Halloween) with a shot-for-shot homage that instantly signals the change in direction. Bloody Disgusting!
- Performances: The ensemble cast do credible work. Characters such as Imogen and Tabby are given stronger early arcs, allowing us to engage with them emotionally. For example, Tabby’s horror-movie-obsessed persona adds meta-texture to the proceedings and gives the show a self-aware edge. Bloody Disgusting!+1
- Visuals & setting: Millwood is depicted as a working-class town, not the glossy suburbia often seen in teen dramas. The high school feels lived-in and the use of past/present framing adds visual depth. Some reviews note that this more grounded aesthetic is a deliberate shift from the “pristine, pretty” world of the original. Reddit
- Shortcomings: A recurring critique is that while the visuals and tone are strong, the character development (particularly for some of the girls) takes a backseat. Several critics felt that three of the five protagonists weren’t fleshed out sufficiently early on. Bloody Disgusting!+1 Some also felt the transition from “I barely know these girls” to “we’re best friends and under siege” happens too fast. Reddit
3. Themes and Messages
- Sins of the past / generational trauma: The core idea — that the current generation of girls are paying for their mothers’ choices 20 years earlier — runs through nearly every story thread. It raises questions of accountability, secrets passed down, and how the “sins” of one era ripple into the next.
- Secrets, surveillance & identity: Much like the original series, the notion that someone knows your darkest secret — and is willing to use it — is central. Here, the covert torment becomes overt threat, heightening the stakes. Bloody Disgusting!+1
- Female friendship and resilience: The show pivots on how these girls must trust each other (despite their differences) and fight back. In a horror-context, their bond becomes a tool of survival rather than just emotional support.
- Class / background / truth vs. appearance: By situating the story in a less glossy town, the show also touches on issues of class and the difference between the “look” of success and the reality of struggle. Some reviews highlight that this setting gives the show a more grounded, less idealised feel than many teen dramas. Reddit
- Relevance to today: While not strictly “holiday” related, the themes of facing the past, of reckoning, and of community support in crisis feel timely – especially in a culture wrestling with generational accountability and the power of secrets.
4. Personal Impressions
I found Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin to be a refreshingly bold take on the franchise. The shift toward horror gives it more bite than I expected. The first few episodes hooked me with credible tension, solid visuals, and characters who felt like they were in real danger, not just emotional peril. The sequence with the high-school party in 1999 (and its fallout) sets a tone of dread immediately, which I appreciated.
I also liked how the show didn’t rely completely on the nostalgia of the original. It references the earlier series’ universe, but largely stands on its own. That gives it a chance to be judged as its own show rather than a pale echo.
That said – there were moments where I felt the pace slowed. Some of the “why don’t you tell someone?” moments felt less credible than they should. Also, the girls’ bond felt slightly under-developed early on (though it strengthens later). If you compare the rapport to the original quartet in the older series, their chemistry didn’t quite reach the same emotional resonance (yet).
Overall, I’d call it a strong entry in the genre, with enough novelty to engage even viewers who aren’t die-hard fans of the original.
5. Audience Recommendations
- If you like teen mysteries with a horror twist (think classic slasher + modern secrets), you’ll probably enjoy this.
- Fans of the original Pretty Little Liars should give it a chance, especially if you’re open to a darker, edgier tone rather than just nostalgia.
- Viewers who enjoy shows about female friendship under pressure, town secrets and the ripple effects of past actions will find plenty to like.
- If you dislike horror elements, or are expecting purely teen drama without any gore or tension, you might find some of the visuals or threats a bit much.
6. Conclusion & Rating
In conclusion: Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin delivers a compelling reinvention of the franchise — stepping beyond its predecessor’s campy soap-mystery roots and heading full-tilt into horror territory. With its strong atmosphere, credible performances and thematic depth, it stands out among teen dramas. While it stumbles a little in character development and pacing, the strengths far outweigh the weaknesses. My final rating: ★★★★☆ (4.0 out of 5)
Watch more:
