1. Plot Summary

The Windmill Massacre follows a group of international tourists, among them Jennifer, an Australian fugitive, who board a bus in Amsterdam to escape their pasts. Their tour bus breaks down in rural Holland. Stranded by a derelict windmill with a sinister history, they begin to experience strange phenomena. Each tourist is haunted by hallucinations or visions connected to their deepest secrets, mistakes, or sins. As one by one they confront these personal demons, a supernatural figure known as “The Miller” begins killing them, wielding a large rusty scythe. The victims must reckon with remorse, guilt, and fear in order to survive—or face death.

2. Notable Elements

• Atmospheric Setting & Folk Horror Roots: The movie leans heavily into eerie rural Netherlands: windmills, barns, lonely countryside. The folklore of the Miller — once a miller who made a deal with the Devil — gives it a mythic, fairy-tale horror feel.
• Character Ensemble & Secrets: Rather than just killing off random victims, the film gives many characters backstories (e.g. Jennifer’s fugitive past, Jackson’s guilt, Nicholas’s past medical errors) that tie into their hallucinations and fears. This adds dimension.
• Supernatural Shadow & Hallucinations: “The Miller” doesn’t just kill physically, but also psychologically, tormenting the characters with vision of past sins, ghost-like apparitions, personal guilt. This supernatural element elevates it above straightforward slashers.
• Visual Style / Gore: Some kills are gruesome and inventive; practical effects are used. There’s a contrast between slow build of horror and bursts of violent kills.

3. Themes & Messages

• Guilt, Remorse, and Redemption: A central theme is how past actions haunt people, sometimes literally in this film. The characters’ remorse or lack thereof plays into whether they are spared or doomed.
• Judgement & Sin: “Sinners” is a label used explicitly in the story, and the Miller is presented as a supernatural judge who punishes those who commit moral wrongs. The idea that one’s inner sins or secrets are not hidden forever.
• Fear of Facing Truth: Beyond external danger, many characters are forced to confront truths they have buried: guilt, shame, fear. The horror isn’t just the monster but themselves.
• The Folkloric / Mythic Evil: The Miller legend (deal with the devil, grinding bones for bread, etc.) references folklore, giving a supernatural moral weight beyond just gore.
Advertisement

4. Personal Impressions

What I liked:

• The film does a good job of blending character drama with horror — I cared about some of the characters because their secrets felt weighty rather than empty clichés.
• The setting is effective: the lonely barns, windmill, rural isolation, night scenes all help build dread.
• The supernatural twist (visions, personal sins) gives more psychological horror, which I find more interesting than just slash and chase.

What didn’t work as well:

• Predictability: After a while, many of the twist-points are foreshadowed heavily, so the direction becomes obvious. Some kills follow common slasher tropes.
• The pacing is uneven: the build is slow in some parts, then sudden spikes in horror; the slow parts sometimes drag or feel repetitive.
• The ending is divisive. Some feel it breaks the rules the movie sets up, or feels abrupt, or less satisfying.

5. Audience Recommendations

You’ll likely enjoy The Windmill Massacre if you:

• Like slashers with a supernatural twist, not just “mask-killer kills people” but with folklore, personal guilt, and psychological torment.
• Enjoy horror where settings contribute strongly to mood and atmosphere.
• Appreciate horror that combines visual gore with something deeper — fear, regret, remorse.

Might be less satisfying for:

• Those who prefer very fast-paced horror with minimal character development and want constant action.
• Viewers who dislike endings that twist the lore or don’t neatly resolve all plot threads.
• Fans who want absolute novelty — the story has many familiar elements, so you might predict what happens.

6. Conclusion & Rating

Overall, The Windmill Massacre is a decent slasher film that adds enough folklore and character depth to make it more than forgettable. It doesn’t reinvent horror, but it delivers solid scares, atmosphere, and some memorable scenes. If you like horror that mixes the supernatural with moral questions, this is worth a watch.

Final Recommendation: Watch it if you’re in the mood for a horror film that’s more than just jump scares — one that makes you think (a little) about what people do, what they hide, and how the past comes back.

Five-Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐ out of 5

Watch more: